|
Updated: 3:11 PM Oct 16, 2009
Legal Drinking Age Debate at Bridgewater College
Bridgewater, Va. The ongoing national debate about the legal drinking age resurfaced at Bridgewater College Thursday night.
Posted: 12:01 AM Oct 16, 2009 |
|
The ongoing national debate about the legal drinking age resurfaced at Bridgewater College Thursday night.
Students were shown recent studies that challenge both sides of the issue: the people for dropping the age to 18 and those who are for keeping it at 21.
As an author, former "Time Magazine" correspondent and parent, Barrett Seaman knows the legal drinking age issue isn't easy.
"My conversations with my daughters were probably pretty much the same as every parent's conversation with their children when they come of age,"
says Seaman.
He says young adults should be allowed to drink at 18, but he admits it's not without risk.
"It's a very tough issue when you have liability laws," says Seaman.
During the debate, Seaman spoke of studies, including one co-authored by his opponent, that say a legal drinking age of 21 had little effect in preventing alcohol abuse and related deaths.
He's says the current drinking age only causes underage people to abuse alcohol more. He gave one example called "pre-gaming," which is when students consume large amounts of alcohol before an activity, because they know they can't legally drink in public.
His opponent disagrees.
"We're talking about maybe 800 to 900 lives that we estimate a legal drinking age of 21 is saving each year. If we lower it back to 18, we could be killing 800 to 900 more youth," says James Fell.
Fell is a senior program director for the Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation. He displayed several studies that suggest lowering the drinking age is dangerous.
One study claims the current law reduce traffic fatalities by 11 percent. Seaman challenged that statistic saying the decline in traffic fatalities was happening before the legal drinking age was set at 21.
Fell showed another study that says some countries where the drinking age is lower are looking to raise it.
Latest Comments
Unfortunately, those numbers are the admittedly squed numbers of the right wing 1980's, the truth is that an additional 600 are dying on the borders of Mexico and Canada making a grand total of 1500. If every state turned to 18 no 18-year olds would drive to any more "blood borders" and there would be no more "drinking age refugees" from the intolerant United States.
I believe as a mother of a 17 and 18 year old, that if this country can send my 18 year old son to Afghanistan, then he should be able to buy a beer. But NO!! we can put there lives on the front line, make them fight for our freedom when really they have none. If you are considered an adult at 18, then you should be able to make adult choices. If they don't want to bring the drinking age to 18, then since they say that smoking kills more people than anything just about, then they need to raise the smoking age to 21. It takes years for smoking to kill you and only one beer, but at 18 you can smoke, so this way we are helping our children kill themselves sooner.
- Lacrosse Murder Defense: Death Was Accident
- Watch: Atlanta Beating Victim: 'I'm the Brave One'
- Watch: New Victim in 40-Year-Old Murder Case?
- Watch: Missouri Teen Sentenced for Killing Neighbor
- Watch: Police Beat Man in Diabetic Shock
- Watch: Judge Orders Couple to Go on a Date
- Watch: Pregnant Teen Shoots Intruder Through Doggie Door
- Watch: Second L.A. Teacher Charged in Sex Abuse Case
- Watch: Plastic Heart Glows With Love
- Prince Harry Named Top of His Class in Apache Helicopter Training
- Watch: Zoo Simulates Rhino Escape
- Watch: Crane Reels in Giant Shark
- Watch: North Korean Musicians Channel A-Ha
- Watch: Inside Japan's Fukushima Exclusion Zone
- Watch: Tensions Rise as Iran 'Flexes' Its Muscle
- Watch: Kidnapped Americans Released in Egypt
- The Global Note: Desperation In Homs…A380 Safety Checks…The Lost Lake…Austerity Vacations
- China's 'Hero Cop' Placed on Leave



